Some advertising slogans are so recognizable that you don’t even need to mention the brand. “Just Do It.” “I’m Lovin’ It.” And, of course, “Maybe she’s born with it. Maybe it’s Maybelline.”
For 35 years, Maybelline’s famous tagline has been one of the beauty industry’s most valuable brand assets. It’s catchy, memorable, and familiar enough to have become part of everyday conversation.
So naturally, Maybelline decided to change it.
The beauty brand recently introduced a new version of its iconic slogan alongside a global campaign starring Miley Cyrus. The updated message is meant to celebrate inclusivity, confidence, and self-expression. But the changes, particularly some very deliberate punctuation, have left plenty of people scratching their heads.
In the latest episode of The Daily Carnage Show, Shannon Sankey takes a closer look at Maybelline’s controversial tagline update, the thinking behind its new brand platform, and the marketing lessons hiding beneath all those extra periods. Want to hear Shannon’s full take? Watch the episode here for a closer look at what happens when a brand decides to reinvent something everyone already loves.
Why Maybelline’s Original Slogan Worked So Well
Maybelline introduced its original tagline in 1991, with supermodel Christy Turlington appearing in the campaign. The idea was simple: Someone sees a woman with incredible lashes or flawless makeup and wonders whether her beauty is natural or the result of Maybelline products.
The tagline created a little moment of curiosity, then gave the audience a memorable answer. It also had a jingle that was nearly impossible to forget.
Over the following decades, the slogan appeared across television, print, celebrity campaigns, and eventually social media. People repeated it, parodied it, and adapted it to situations that had absolutely nothing to do with makeup.
That’s an extraordinary achievement for a piece of advertising copy. Maybelline had created something people recognized without needing an explanation. The slogan had become part of popular culture.
And the brand already knew how difficult that was to replace.
In 2016, Maybelline moved away from its famous line in favor of “Make It Happen,” a message focused on confidence and empowerment. The replacement never achieved the same recognition, and the brand eventually returned to a shortened version of its original slogan.
As NewBeauty’s look at the tagline’s history explains, Maybelline reported that 84% of consumers still recognized the original line when the brand revisited it in 2024. That’s the kind of brand equity marketers spend entire careers trying to build.
Meet Maybelline’s New Slogan
On November 10, 2026, Maybelline officially introduced its updated tagline: “Maybe. We’re born with it. Maybe. It’s Maybelline.”
The change is part of a new global brand platform called The Beauty of Infinite Possibility, featuring Miley Cyrus as its ambassador.
According to Maybelline’s official announcement, the campaign is designed to reflect a broader understanding of beauty, emphasizing confidence, creativity, and the freedom to express different versions of yourself.
Rather than presenting beauty as something someone naturally possesses, Maybelline wants to encourage people to explore what beauty can mean to them.
It’s a reasonable direction for a brand trying to connect with changing consumer expectations. And Miley Cyrus makes sense as the face of that message.
Her career has been defined by creative reinvention, from changes in musical style to completely different visual identities. She represents the idea that people can evolve without losing their individuality.
Maybelline also wants this campaign to become something bigger than a single advertisement.
The Beauty of Infinite Possibility is intended to connect future product launches, partnerships, brand experiences, and storytelling under one central message. There’s plenty to like about that strategy.
The actual wording, however, is where things get interesting.
One Word Changed. Then Came the Punctuation.
Maybelline made two intentional changes to its famous slogan. The first replaces “she’s” with “we’re.”
It’s a small adjustment that makes the message more inclusive. Instead of referring to one idealized woman, the slogan now speaks to a broader community.
That change fits naturally with the campaign’s emphasis on self-expression and the idea that beauty isn’t limited to one particular standard.
In an interview with Cosmetics Business, Maybelline Global Brand President Sandrine Jolly explained that the shift from an individual to a collective perspective was intended to make the message more inclusive.
It’s a thoughtful update that preserves much of what made the original slogan recognizable. But Maybelline didn’t stop there.
The second change introduces periods after each use of “Maybe.”
According to the brand, the punctuation transforms the word from an expression of uncertainty into a declaration of possibility. In theory, it’s a clever bit of copywriting.
In practice, it takes a phrase that once flowed naturally and turns it into something that requires a surprisingly detailed explanation.
And that creates a problem.
The original slogan worked because people understood it immediately. The rhythm, the wordplay, and the connection to the product were all built into the line.
The new version asks consumers to interpret the punctuation before they can fully appreciate the intended message. For a slogan that has spent 35 years being effortlessly memorable, that’s a pretty significant tradeoff.
Why the Internet Isn’t Loving the Change
Maybelline’s new tagline has generated plenty of conversation, although much of it isn’t focused on the campaign’s intended message.
As The Guardian reported on reactions to the update, critics have questioned the unusual punctuation, the awkward rhythm, and whether the changes improve the original slogan at all.
Some reactions are rooted in nostalgia. Others are simply confused about why the brand felt the need to complicate something so familiar. And there’s a fair marketing question underneath the jokes.
Does the new punctuation actually communicate confidence and possibility to consumers? Or does it only make sense after someone from the marketing department explains what it represents?
The campaign’s broader message is compelling. Beauty can be creative, personal, and constantly evolving.
But the conversation surrounding the launch has become heavily focused on the slogan’s grammar. That’s probably not what Maybelline intended.
Of course, controversy can generate attention. People are discussing the brand, sharing opinions, and revisiting a tagline that’s been around for decades.
But attention alone doesn’t tell us whether the new message is resonating. And that distinction matters.
What Marketers Can Learn From Maybelline’s Rebrand
There’s a lot to unpack here beyond whether three additional periods were a good creative decision.
Brand equity deserves protection. Maybelline spent decades building recognition around its original slogan. That familiarity has real value, and changing a recognizable brand asset should involve a clear understanding of what might be lost.
Evolve the meaning before changing the message. Maybelline’s broader campaign introduces a relevant perspective on beauty, confidence, and individuality. The shift from “she’s” to “we’re” also supports that direction. The brand could arguably have communicated its new philosophy while preserving more of the original tagline’s rhythm.
Clever copy still needs to be clear. There’s nothing wrong with exploring language creatively. But a slogan should communicate its message without requiring an explanation from the brand president. If consumers need a footnote to understand the intended meaning, the copy may be working harder than it needs to.
Engagement isn’t always evidence of success. The backlash has generated discussion, but much of that conversation centers on the punctuation rather than the brand’s message about self-expression. Marketers should look beyond mentions and impressions to understand what people are actually taking away from a campaign.
Consistency can be a competitive advantage. Recognizable brand assets help people identify and remember a company. Maintaining those assets over time can be just as valuable as introducing something new.
These lessons apply well beyond beauty marketing.
Brands regularly face pressure to refresh their identities, update their messaging, and demonstrate that they’re keeping up with cultural change.
Sometimes those changes are necessary. Other times, the more interesting creative challenge is finding a new way to use something that already works.
Does Every Iconic Slogan Need a Makeover?
Maybelline has a legitimate reason to rethink how it communicates beauty.
Consumer expectations have evolved, and a message built around self-expression, individuality, and confidence makes sense for the brand today.
The Beauty of Infinite Possibility offers plenty of room for creative storytelling, especially with someone like Miley Cyrus leading the campaign.
But the new tagline raises an important question about how brands approach evolution. How much do you really need to change when people already recognize and love what you’ve built?
Maybelline’s original slogan survived decades of changing beauty standards, advertising trends, and cultural conversations. That flexibility was part of its strength.
The new version may eventually become just as familiar. Consumers could embrace it once the initial reactions settle down.
Or Maybelline might discover that the best way to modernize an iconic brand asset is to give it a new context while leaving the words alone.
Maybe the new slogan will grow on us. Maybe it won’t. Maybe. It’s Maybelline.



